Image TCA: Aleksandr Potolitsyn

The Middle Corridor is Being Funded Faster than Expected

By Robert M. Cutler

 

According to Samuel Doveri Vesterbye, director of the independent think-tank, European Neighbourhood Council (ENC), a small group of high-ranking cabinet officials, ambassadors and other diplomats met in a closed-door round-table on May 15, representing the EU, Türkiye and countries in the South Caucasus and Central Asia. The meeting, organized by Turkish organizations International Transporters Association (UND) and the Turkish Industry and Business Association (TUSIAD), focused on the synergy between the EU’s Global Gateway initiative and the projects of the Trans-Caspian International Trade Route (TITR).

The fact of the meeting taking place has been confirmed by Türkiye’s Permanent Delegate to the EU. Doveri Vesterbye writes that the meeting “consisted of less than 30 individuals mostly linked to diplomacy, transport, logistics, business, critical infrastructure security, policy-making and supply chains” and “brought together four different Directorate Generals (DGs) and more than 10 nationalities of Director-and-Ambassador level.” Significantly, also according to Doveri Vesterbye, the development of high-level coordination committees is under way.

The meeting’s assessment that the TITR is being funded faster than expected is an extremely positive development. Dr. S. Frederick Starr, a well-known American expert and a Distinguished Fellow for Eurasia at the American Foreign Policy Council, told The Times of Central Asia that “the activation and coordination of both European and Turkish institutions is essential not only for the financing and construction of this mega-project, but also for its successful management thereafter.”

This is a very stabilizing development for international commerce. As other corridors are increasingly volatile, it would help to insulate trade between China and Europe from supply-chain shocks. It will also benefit the participating states themselves. Starr explained that the continuing European and Turkish involvement in building out the TITR “will help the transit states of Central Asia and the [South] Caucasus to balance their relations with China and Europe and will thereby undergird their sovereignties. Such balance creates what is literally a ‘win-win-win’ situation.”

According to a mid-2023 report, prepared jointly by the EBRD and the EU Commission, an estimated €18.5 billion is required in infrastructure investments in order to improve Central Asia’s transport connectivity. Potential growth in transit container traffic by 2040 could be over 40-fold, with significant spill-over effects on education, tech hubs, business and middle-class development.

At the same time, the TITR has been reconceptualized as a driver of regional trade and economic growth along the entire Europe–Türkiye–South Caucasus–Central Asia trajectory, with special attention given to the latter two regions. The EU Commission and the EBRD have already funded €10.5 billion in Central Asia via loans and grant investments promised only a few months ago, in January this year, at the Global Gateway Investment Forum in Brussels. This pace suggests significant commitment by such large bureaucratic organizations, and it augurs well for the unlocking of funds from the European Investment Bank (EIB) for investment in Turkey.

Doveri Vesterbye writes that the heads of EU member-state missions in Brussels (COREPER) will work to synchronize EIB investments, with special attention on reforming the Customs Union, in order to prepare EU decisions in this direction. For example, such seeming minutiae as the facilitation of issuing visas to truck drivers from Türkiye requires attention in order to implement EBRD recommendations to diminish costs associated with otherwise longer waiting times at borders.

Other main recommendations, including from the World Bank report of last year, are to implement digitization, particularly at border-crossings, cut red-tape, including customs-declaration paperwork, and improve logistical bottlenecks. In this last respect, truck transit needs to be improved both in the short and the medium term, and rail transit in the longer term.

More recent work, executed on the basis of the EBRD study, projects that investments of €16.5 billion to improve regulatory frameworks and infrastructure connectivity will increase container traffic from 100,000 Twenty-foot Equivalent Units (TEU, a standard cargo unit equivalent to approximately 35 cubic meters) to 865,000 TEU. This would also decrease Asia–Europe transit times from a month or more to fewer than 13 days. The next EU Commission and European Parliament will likely play a role in the corridor’s development by encouraging or requiring energy investments in hydrogen, solar and wind power for electricity-generation.

More recently, Doveri Vesterbye argues that the Middle Corridor’s assistance in Europe’s relocation of supply chains will help the EU to achieve its desired global strategic autonomy. Elements contributing to this development would include diversification from Chinese raw-material sources at still-competitive economic prices, as well as the maintenance of control over strategic supply and production chains through access to inexpensive energy and key rare metals.

The Middle Corridor is being realized faster than expected, although continued fine-grained attention is necessary for its most efficient implementation. It is part and parcel of the ongoing reconfiguration of global supply chains that will continue over the next decade and a half, as the international system reaches the crisis of tensions arising from the ongoing bifurcation between “Sinosphere” and “Anglosphere” trade routes.

Whether the EU will be able use the build-out of the Middle Corridor to rein Türkiye back towards a Western orientation in the post-Erdogan era remains to be seen. What is clear is that the vision of a robust and efficient Middle Corridor is steadily materializing. The long-term benefits of this initiative extend beyond immediate trade efficiencies. Synchronizing investments and focusing on the modernization of infrastructure will significantly boost the economies of the transit states. In the best of all possible worlds, enhanced connectivity will spur regional development, promote the rise of tech hubs and help to grow a robust middle class in part through increased educational opportunities.

The EU is succeeding in recruiting the Middle Corridor countries into its program emphasizing investments in sustainable energy investments, including hydrogen production and transmission. At a minimum, successful implementation will increase Europe’s resilience against external supply chain disruptions. An often-overlooked consequence is the enhancement of the role of the countries along the Middle Corridor in shaping the outcome of the structural crisis of the international system, which will play out over the next 20–30 years.

Avatar

Times of Central Asia

photo: Kazakhstan Ministry of Transport

Test Run of Trans-Caspian Route from China to Europe via Kazakhstan

At a meeting of the Kazakh-Chinese commission on road transportation on 24 May in Aktau, Kazakhstan’s Ministry of Transport reported on a test  run of the transit of goods along the China-Kazakhstan-Azerbaijan-Georgia route through the seaports of Kuryk and Baku across the Caspian Sea.

On 23 May, the first three Chinese trucks, weighing 80 tons, travelled from Urumqi through Kazakhstan to the city of Aktau’s Kuryk port and after being loaded onto a ferry, continued their journey to Azerbaijan, Georgia, and Europe.

Praising the agreement with China on enhancing road transportation signed last year, Ali Altai, Chairman of the Committee for Road Transport and Transport Control at the Ministry of Transport of Kazakhstan, commented: “For the first time in history, vehicles from both countries can travel directly to all our major trading cities and transit through their territories. It currently takes up to 52 days for hundreds of millions of tons of cargo to be shipped by sea from China to Western countries, and up to 22 days to transport smaller volumes by rail. Road transport can reduce the delivery time to 12 days, on a ‘door to door’ basis without intermediate loading/unloading.”

Avatar

Times of Central Asia

Image: TravelPress.kz

Why Have Women’s Carriages Become So Popular in Kazakhstan?

Kazakhstani women have already had time to appreciate women-only cars in trains – an innovation that seemed unthinkable in the secular country a few years ago. However, the special carriages did not appear as an indulgence to traditionalist views.

Kazakhstani women now have a choice: they can ride in a regular carriage, or they can ride in a carriage that is practically closed to men – and demand for the latter service is increasing year by year.

In May, the statistics of Kazakhstan Temir Zholy (KTZ), a railroad monopoly, were published, which revealed that women twice as often choose women’s cars. Since 2021, more than 359,000 women have chosen this option, and since the beginning of 2024 alone, the service has been used by about 70,000 women, whereas in 2023, only 34,000 did so.

Today, women’s cars run in eight long-distance passenger trains, with only female conductors working in them. Male children up to seven-years-old are allowed, whilst men can go enter for a short period of time, but overnight stays are strictly prohibited.

The need to ensure the safety of women in trains began to be discussed after the scandal that broke out in the fall of 2018, when two conductors raped a female passenger on the high-speed train “Talgo” on the Astana-Aktobe route. This crime resonated widely, and led to loud demands for the authorities to take action. Conductors Zhetes Umbetaliev and Kolkanat Kurmaniyazov were found guilty of rape in July 2019 and were sentenced to just 2.3 and 2.5 years, respectively, whilst Kanat Almagambetov, first deputy chairman of KTZ, apologized on behalf of the company.

The first women-only cars were launched in October 2021. “This is being done primarily for the safety of women… If demand for the service increases, our company is ready to expand the geography of these routes. Apart from the female conductors, these carriages are no different from the others. They have the same pricing policy,” KTZ explained at the time.

The current routes were chosen because of their length, company representatives said. Kazakhstan is a large country and a trip from Almaty to Mangistau, for example, takes several days.

Ainagul Kasenova, a resident of Mangistau Oblast, travels to see relatives in Almaty several times a year, and for her, women’s cars have become a solution. “Now I try to buy tickets only in a separate car. You travel for a long time, so it’s much more comfortable if there are only women and children around. I used to encounter men talking to me, paying me unnecessary attention; it was unpleasant. When the news about the rape of a female passenger by conductors broke, my parents didn’t even want to let me go to Almaty. Now they let me go without any problem,” Kasenova told TCA.

According to her, both students and pensioners are comfortable in women’s carriages, especially those who have to travel often, which increases the risk. “The women’s carriage is always quiet, friendly atmosphere, without drinking and noise,” she added.

The demand for women’s carriages seems set to grow; Kazakhstani women are increasingly fearful of violence, and they have good reason to be. A study published by the Karaganda Medical University says that statistics on domestic crimes against women are steadily worsening.

The study is based on statistics from the Ministry of Justice and on a survey of 14,342 women of different ages (from 18 to 75) from 2019 to 2022, conducted in 14 regions of Kazakhstan. In particular, in 2022, the number of reports to the police for domestic violence amounted to more than 125,000. This is almost twice as many as in 2021 (63,447). The study showed that the main victims of domestic violence in Kazakhstan are women (77.9%), followed by children (17.52%).

The report states that in only 12.2% of cases is violence against women committed by strangers. In 87.8% of cases, the perpetrators are men with whom the victims are in a close relationship, almost all whom are husbands or partners of the victims (95-98% of cases). The data also show that most episodes of violence against women (98.2%) are caused by the alcohol intoxication of the assailant.

Although the percentage of unknown persons or casual acquaintances who have harmed a woman is so not high compared to domestic tyrants, the risk of stumbling upon a perpetrator in the transportation network increases many times over. Researchers note that Kazakhstan still has a high level of domestic violence, the main reasons for which include poverty, corruption, and low levels of education,

In the wake of the death of Saltanat Nukenova, which saw former Minister of National Economy Kuandyk Bishimbayev sentenced to 24 years in prison for the torture and murder of his common-law wife after a live-streamed trial, an open discussion on the issue of domestic violence has come to the fore in Kazakhstan. In April 2024, President Tokayev signed a new law onto the statute book in line with OECD standards which tightens the penalties for domestic violence and provides more help for survivors.

Avatar

Times of Central Asia

World Bank loan

World Bank Helps Improve Social Services for Vulnerable People in Uzbekistan

On 24 May, the World Bank’s Board of Executive Directors approved a $100 million concessional loan for an Innovative Social Protection System for Inclusion of Vulnerable People Project to improve access to, and the quality of social services for vulnerable people in Uzbekistan.

The project is co-financed by a $2 million grant from the Early Learning Partnership; a multi-donor trust fund managed by the World Bank to support vulnerable children’s development and learning. The grant will be used to evaluate and improve social services’ provision for the well-being of vulnerable children in Uzbekistan’s local communities or ‘mahallas.’

Welcoming the government’s commitment to broadening the nation’s social protection system and provide more inclusive and effective support to vulnerable people, Marco Mantovanelli, World Bank Country Manager for Uzbekistan, commented: “This project will help build the legal and institutional foundations of the care economy. It will also expand access to quality on-demand social services that are currently underprovided to thousands of vulnerable people across the country, including older people, persons with disabilities, survivors of gender-based violence, and vulnerable children.”

The project will be implemented by the National Social Protection Agency through the Office of the President of Uzbekistan, in close collaboration with various government agencies, non-governmental organizations, and Uzbekistan’s international development partners.

Over 50 community-based territorial social service centers (TSSCs) will be established across the country to improve access to enhanced social care and rehabilitation facilities for over 50,000 vulnerable citizens, including the elderly, people with disabilities, and vulnerable children.

The project will also create a platform for a regulated and accredited provision of social services from the private sector and by encouraging external investment, reduce the strain on the state’s institutional-based care and welfare system.

Once in operation, the project will equip 1,200 people with disabilities, at least half whom are aged 15-24, with professional skills and employment opportunities. Women will also benefit from legal, health and psychological services offered by the establishment of 29 Women Adaptation and Rehabilitation Centers.

Last but not least, the initiative will lay the foundations for shock-responsive social protection in Uzbekistan, including the development of policies, emergency procedures and the piloting of a new climate adaptation program. Serving 100,000 impoverished people living in rural communities, the program is designed to increase awareness of climate-related risks and improve communities’ resilience through the provision of seeds for climate-resistant crops, tools, and training in climate-smart agriculture and climate adaptation practices.

 

Avatar

Times of Central Asia

photo: US Embassy in Kyrgyzstan

US Donates 12,000 English-Language Books to Schools and Libraries in Kyrgyzstan

The United States has donated over 12,000 English-language books to 30 schools, libraries, and universities in the Osh, Jalal-Abad, and Batken regions of south Kyrgyzstan.

The much-welcomed project is the initiative of a collaboration between the Rotary Club of the Fergana Valley, the Women’s Peace Bank Public Foundation, Osh State University, the U.S. Embassy, and the Kyrgyz government. The Rotary Club of Annapolis’ “Books for International Goodwill” project played a key role in securing book donations.

The donation includes books for all ages – children to adults – and covering a wide range of subjects, is an invaluable resource for learning the English language.

“These books are more than just paper and ink,” said U.S. Ambassador to the Kyrgyz Republic Lesslie Viguerie. “They are keys that unlock the world of English language learning and bridges connecting the people of the Kyrgyz Republic and the United States.”

The donation was further praised by Akylai Karim, Project Leader at the Rotary Club of Fergana Valley and Women Peace Bank, who announced:  “This initiative is a celebration of the Kyrgyz-American friendship, trust, and collaboration. It will have a lasting, positive impact as youth learn English by reading these books and dream big about their future.”

 

Avatar

Times of Central Asia

@iStock

Kyrgyz Banks Urged to Unite and Create Single ATM Network

The chairman of the Cabinet of Ministers of Kyrgyzstan, Akylbek Zhaparov, has urged the consolidation of the nation’s ATMs into one network in a speech at the Bishkek International Financial Forum, stating that the government has been unable to reduce commissions on transfers through banks for two years. 24.kg reports.

“This problem has always been there, and it has hindered us. But today, when we are working on the transfer of most payments on a cashless basis, you cannot expect a passive position from us. I have addressed both the National Bank and the Ministry of Economy several times and entrusted the issue to the Ministry of Economy. Therefore, it’s probably time for us to study and adopt the experience of other countries on legislative regulation of fee collection for inter-bank transfers,” said Zhaparov.

The Cabinet of Ministers believes that banks should stop spending a lot of money on installing ATMs as this wastes time and resources, and proposes that banks unite and create a single ATM structure. Zhaparov emphasized the development of digital payment technologies and increasing the share of non-cash payments as essential growth pillars, noting that work is being done in two directions to implement the digital concept: choosing the right technological solution and harmonizing legislative acts to introduce the legal status of the digital system.

“The introduction of the digital som contributes to the country’s economic development by providing a more efficient payment system and stimulating innovation in financial technology. We are pursuing the goal of increasing innovation capacity in the banking sector. Realizing the possibility of protected and secure information exchange between the banking sector participants will allow the development of new products and services and increase their availability and integration,” said Zhaparov.

Avatar

Times of Central Asia